Saturday, February 3, 2024

READERS' CHOICE #31: ROBOCOP (1987)

THRILL SCALE 1-10

9.5

HAVE I SEEN IT BEFORE?

Yes, but only once, and within the last few years

BEST SEQUENCE

RoboCop's first night on the beat; our introduction to ED-209 is also pretty memorable

BEST LINE

"I'd buy that for a dollar"

ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE

92%

ROTTEN TOMATOES CRITICS CONSENSUS

"While over-the-top and gory, Robocop is also a surprisingly smart sci-fi flick that uses ultraviolence to disguise its satire of American culture."

IMDB SYNOPSIS

"In a dystopic and crime-ridden Detroit, a terminally wounded cop returns to the force as a powerful cyborg haunted by submerged memories."

DIRECTOR

Paul Verhoeven

MAIN CAST

Peter Weller, Ronny Cox, Kurtwood Smith, Nancy Allen, Miguel Ferrer, Daniel O'Herlihy

THOUGHTS
  • Man, this is such an entertaining movie
  • The violence is indeed extremely graphic, but it's also pretty absurd in both style and amount, letting us know that we shouldn't take it too seriously. Scenes like ED-209 pumping a guy full of lead in a board meeting, or a bad guy driving into a tank of toxic waste, only for his disintegrating body to then explode on a car's windshield after getting run over, in a different movie they might make us recoil in horror or disgust; in RoboCop they're so over-the-top that you can't help but laugh along with the movie. In fact, for level of violence it's not that far removed from something like Ichi the Killer, but RoboCop does more that I like with it
  • The ridiculousness of the movie also leads to a lot of affection for the somewhat janky special effects. For example, I love that RoboCop's robotic motions are pretty much shown just through Peter Weller (very capably) popping and locking. I haven't seen the 2014 remake, so I could be wrong, but I would imagine that a more modern movie would lean into CGI or actual robotics in the costuming to make the lead character more believable as a machine. But then you watch this movie, and you realize - who cares if he's not always 100% believable as a robot? It really doesn't matter how convincing it is, because everyone onscreen sells it
  • The same could be said about ED-209, very charmingly depicted through stop motion or just by pushing a model down some stairs (one of the funniest parts of the movie). But when people scream and flee from an attacking ED-209, we believe it completely
  • As an example of a legitimately impressive and convincing special effect, I'll mention when RoboCop takes off his helmet and we see Peter Weller's face on a robotic head. Although, to balance things out, it's only fair to then mention the least convincing special effect of the movie, the hilariously elongated limbs on the Dick Jones model when he gets shot out of a window (but it's also completely unforgettable and I wouldn't change it for the world)
  • The special effects team was led by Rob Bottin, whose fantastic work we've talked about before (The Thing) and we will again (Se7en)
  • Clarence Boddicker and Dick Jones are unbeatable bad guy names, backed up by delightfully villainous performances by Kurtwood Smith and Ronny Cox
  • It was really hard to choose a favourite line for this one, as the script is eminently quotable. Also in the running: "Can you fly, Bobby?"; "Your move, creep"; Dead or alive, you're coming with me"; and, of course, "I used to call the Old Man funny names - Iron Butt. Boner. Once, I even called him...asshole."
  • Finally, so many components work together so well in this movie, but I would be remiss if I didn't mention the man who brought them all together, Paul Verhoeven. It will be his only appearance in these reviews (unless I decide to add another one on a whim), but what a great showing it is. I especially loved all his little directorial flourishes, things like the newscasts and commercials and bad TV shows that interrupt the action onscreen (the commercial for Nukem is probably my favourite), or the POV shots, like RoboCop booting up after Murphy is brought back to life. I haven't seen all of Verhoeven's movies, but I've liked everything I've seen; even Showgirls, which as a movie is completely abysmal, but as a viewing experience is sublime. Am I right to think that RoboCop is Verhoeven's best movie? Or would anyone like to make a case for another contender in his filmography?
Up next: And with that, we've finished another block of Readers' Choice movies, so it's back into the AFI list with The Sixth Sense! And after that we'll be spending a bit more time with M. Night Shyamalan. He may not have the most consistent body of work, but you can't call him a quitter. So we'll be watching a few more Shyamalan movies as well, to be decided by readers' votes

Friday, January 19, 2024

READERS' CHOICE #32: GONE GIRL (2014)

THRILL SCALE 1-10

6

HAVE I SEEN IT BEFORE?

Yes, once, in the theatre

BEST SEQUENCE

The midway point of the movie when we learn what happened on the day of Amy's disappearance

BEST LINE

"When I think of my wife, I always think of her head. I picture cracking her lovely skull, unspooling her brains, trying to get answers. The primal questions of any marriage: What are you thinking? How are you feeling? What have we done to each other?"
- First line of the movie, voiceover by Nick (Ben Affleck)

ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE

88%

ROTTEN TOMATOES CRITICS CONSENSUS

"Dark, intelligent, and stylish to a fault, Gone Girl plays to director David Fincher's sick strengths while bringing the best out of stars Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike."

IMDB SYNOPSIS

"With his wife's disappearance having become the focus of an intense media circus, a man sees the spotlight turned on him when it's suspected that he may not be innocent."

DIRECTOR

David Fincher

MAIN CAST

Rosamund Pike, Ben Affleck, Carrie Coon, Neil Patrick Harris, Tyler Perry, Kim Dickens

THOUGHTS
  • As has happened a few times before, 6 might seem like a low score but even if Gone Girl isn't as thrilling as some of the other movies we've talked about, it's still an undeniably excellent, entertaining movie and I liked the experience of watching it quite a lot more than the 6 might imply
  • As has also happened before, a lot of the thrill value comes from the way the movie's plot twists and turns and it's entirely possible I'd be giving this a higher score if I hadn't seen it already, just based on shock value. Which is also a good time to give a spoiler warning for what follows, and if you haven't seen Gone Girl, stop reading and watch it
  • David Fincher is certainly well-represented on the Readers' Choice list - we've already talked about The Game, and eventually we'll talk about Se7en, and I believe this gives him the most movies on the Readers' Choice list (but there are a number of directors with two films each)
  • On the other hand I do believe this is the first and only appearance of Ben Affleck (also of Rosamund Pike, but Affleck has been in more movies which might be included on a "thrilling movie" list). Affleck and Pike are both really excellent in this, showing just enough to the audience so that we know there's more going on than they're letting on, but they're also still cagey enough that we're treated to some genuine, shocking surprises
  • As mentioned above, my pick for the best sequence is when we learn what actually happened on the day that Amy disappeared, and we see exactly how much planning and plotting went into the events of that day, all perfectly explained by Pike's voiceover
  • Just as intriguing is when Amy's plan starts to unravel and we see her need to pivot and think on her feet, but still with the same cunning, calculated methodology. I also liked this section of the movie for the parallel stories, almost a cat-and-mouse between Nick and Amy
  • And this part of the movie culminates in the actual most thrilling scene, at least for me - the death of Neil Patrick Harris's Desi. Shocking and brutal, but also pretty satisfying because he was a terrible person in his own way
  • Along with Harris, the rest of the supporting cast is also great. I especially liked Carrie Coon in her film debut as Nick's sister, and Kim Dickens as the lead investigator on the case
  • Finally, a bit of a tangent. I first saw Gone Girl in the theatre in 2014 and it shall forever remain in my memory as the absolute worst I've ever had to pee during a movie, and I hope it never has a contender. I was feeling it for probably the last 3/4 of the movie, starting with mild discomfort and turning into outright agony towards the end. AND YET, I just couldn't allow myself to leave the theatre and potentially miss something huge so I just gritted my teeth and sat there, bladder close to bursting. Ever since then I've made it a habit to use the washroom before the movie starts, which anyone could tell you is a good idea anyway, but I do give Gone Girl bonus points for grabbing my attention to such an extent that I don't think I'll ever forget it (although on this rewatch I did make use of the pause button with 20 minutes left to go)
Up next: The last Readers' Choice movie of this group, and it's a big one. Robocop, from 1987

Thursday, December 28, 2023

READERS' CHOICE #33: PET SEMATARY (1989) - GUEST REVIEW BY ASHLEY

TW: Suicide, child death
THRILL SCALE 1-10

8

HAVE I SEEN IT BEFORE?

Yes, a few times

BEST SEQUENCE

My personal fave is Gage vs. Truck, but the Zelda scene is also very memorable

BEST LINE

"Sometimes dead is better" (the tagline)

ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE

55%

ROTTEN TOMATOES CRITICS CONSENSUS

"Pet Sematary is a bruising horror flick that wears its quirks on its sleeves, to the detriment of its scare factor."

IMDB SYNOPSIS

"After tragedy strikes, a grieving father discovers an ancient burial ground behind his home with the power to raise the dead."

DIRECTOR

Mary Lambert

MAIN CAST

  • Dale Midkiff, Fred Gwynne, Denise Crosby, Miko Hughes, Blaze Berdahl, Brad Greenquist

THOUGHTS
  • Spoily alert, I'm going to tell you the whole movie
  • The movie starts out with a delightfully creepy score as we're introduced to the "Pet Sematary". We see various pet graves/epitaphs. It's sad, eerie, but also sort of sweet. This opening credit sequence does a nice job of setting up a spooky atmosphere
  • Enter the Creed family: Dr. Louis Creed, wife Rachel, daughter Ellie (played by twins), son Gage, and cat Church (short for Winston Churchill - a pretty great name for a cat). Louis is smokin' hot in this writer's opinion btw (apparently this part was almost played by Bruce Campbell). We meet the family as they arrive to their new home, which is located on a road where transport trucks whiz by in a very sinister, foreshadow-y way
  • Next we meet the neighbour from across the street, Jud Crandall (Fred Gwynne). This character is played just as I always imagined him from reading the book, right down to his classic "A-yuh" responses. His accent is lots of fun to imitate and he smokes like a chimney. Jud takes the Creed family down to the Pet Sematary (here Rachel comments on the misspelling), which is conveniently accessed from a path on their property. He points out where he buried his childhood dog and recommends they get their cat fixed so he's less likely to wander  
  • On Louis's first day at his new job, a jogger named Victor Pascow is brought in, having been hit by a truck. Here we see some great practical gore effects as the poor guy's head is basically half smashed. There's clearly no saving him. The dead man then wakes, talks some nonsense, and says he'll be back. Talk about a rough first day. I love this character and how he's played in this movie. He's scary, funny, helpful, and his jogging shorts are amazing. Later, Pascow comes to Louis in a dream, taking him to the Pet Sematary and warning him not to go beyond the barrier (a huge wall of trees/branches, ominously glowing blue). Louis wakes up with his feet covered in mud (DUN DUN DUN)!
  • Fast forward to Thanksgiving. Rachel takes the kids to her parents' while Louis stays home (he doesn't get along with the in-laws). Shocker: poor Church the cat is hit by a truck. Jud takes Louis to the place beyond the Pet Sematary, has him bury the cat, and instructs him not to tell anyone. The journey to the ancient burial ground is arduous. The fact that Louis blindly follows his old-ass, chain-smoking neighbour, basically up a tree covered cliff for well over an hour, without any idea where they're going and why seems silly. The next day, Church comes home. He smells like death (ha!) and is now vicious. Jud confides that he buried his childhood dog there and that he came back different too. WHAT THE EFF, JUD!?
  • Did I mention the Creeds have a housekeeper? Her name is Missy and she's miserable. We learn that she has stomach cancer and she ends up hanging herself to free herself from the pain. At her funeral, Stephen King plays the minister. I actually completely forgot about this mini plot-point, but as unnecessary as it seems, it gives us our sweet sweet cameo and inspires Rachel to tell Louis about her sister Zelda...
  • Meet Zelda. Rachel's dead sister. She was kept locked away and suffered from spinal meningitis. For many viewers, this is the scene that causes nightmares. Zelda (played by a man) has a scary, raspy voice, gaunt face, and deformed spine. She basically looks like a monster. As Rachel tells the story of being left alone with her on the night she died, my face is always stuck in a grimace. It's both horrible and horrifying. On the plus side, it gives Rachel's character some substance. Up until now, she's pretty bland
  • Next comes my favourite scene in the movie. It's a beautiful day and the Creeds and ole Jud are having a picnic and flying a kite. Despite the cheesy music, we know right away that something bad is coming as we're shown a transport truck driver barrelling down the road. As Gage is flying the kite, the family is distracted by a gust of wind. Gage drops the kite string and begins to chase it towards the road. The family finally notices what's happening, but it's too late. We see a single shoe land on the road. This image has always stood out to me and the sequence as a whole has always filled me with such dread. The entire scene is so effective and even though we know we can't stop what's going to happen, we're on the edge of our seats  
  • Another great scene takes place at Gage's funeral. Rachel's father confronts Louis, blaming him for Gage's death. There's a scuffle and the two men end up knocking over the coffin. As it falls to the floor, the lid opens briefly and we see Gage's little hand for just a second before it closes again. Super creepy 
  • Rachel brings Ellie to her parents' place and once again we see that men can not be left alone. Louis gets the bright idea to dig up his son's grave and bury him in the ancient burial ground (this is after Jud has told him of someone trying this in the past and it going very wrong..). By this point, Dr. Lou Lou has gone cray cray (we see this very obviously as he's digging up Gage). Zombie Gage comes back and gives us a seriously impressive performance for a 2 year old (this actor would go on to star in Kindergarten Cop and another fave of mine, Wes Craven's New Nightmare). As Louis sleeps, Gage takes one of his scalpels and goes to Jud's house. Here we have some very obvious foreshadowing as Jud shuffles around in his slippers looking for Gage, the camera focused on his ankles. Sure enough, Gage reaches out from under the bed and slices Jud's achilles, giving us another great gore shot. Gage finishes off Jud, somehow calls his dad on the phone (can't explain that one), and invites him over to "play" 
  • Meanwhile, Rachel is rushing back home after Ellie has had a bad dream about her father. And lucky for Rachel (and us!), Pascow is back to save the day! He uses his ghostly powers to help her catch her flight and get the last rental car! Thanks Pascow! (Fun little easter egg - when Rachel gets out of the truck she got a ride in, we see that the truck number is "666". SpOoKy!) She gets home and goes straight to Jud's because she hears a voice. She's so happy when she sees Gage, but of course he's evil now and kills her. Also, we get some real "Chucky" vibes from lil Gage in these scenes. Very fun!
  • Let's wrap this up: Louis makes it over to Jud's, discovers what has happened, puts Gage to "sleep" with some doctor drugs, lights the place on fire, and decides to BURY RACHEL IN THE BURIAL GROUND! Dr. Creed, you are hot, but damn you are dumb. Men, am I right!?
  • Louis waits up for his dead wife to return. In she saunters, and girl is looking rough. Like, pus coming out of her eyeball rough. It's actually pretty awesome until they start making out. In the original cut, the scene was more ambiguous, ending when Rachel entered the kitchen. The studio thought it was too tame, so it was re-shot with much more gruesome effects. The audience sees Rachel reach for a knife during their embrace, Louis screams, cut to black
  • To sum up, I love this movie. I love the gore, the characters, even the silly, unbelievable bits (like Louis wrestling what is clearly a dummy version of Gage). It's fun and it's memorable. And while the story has some minor deviations from the book, I think that SK writing the screenplay really helped to keep the same spirit of the original story. I have seen the sequel and very much enjoyed it (more great practical effects), but have yet to see the 2019 remake
  • Looking back at my notes, I see that I wrote "Jud and his Buds". This was a reference to all the Budweisers he drinks. Just wanted you all to know. Other things I wrote : "Hot Doctor Daddy", "Men are idiots", "Church's eyes" (forgot to mention their cheesy glow)
  • Kudos to my husband for writing these things. I need a drink now
Up next: Oh hey, it's me, Mark again! Thanks to my wonderful wife Ashley for the review, she did an excellent job! Which is convenient because our next movie is also about a wonderful wife who does an excellent job: Gone Girl from 2014

Sunday, December 17, 2023

READERS' CHOICE #34-C: IT CHAPTER TWO (2019)

THRILL SCALE 1-10

6.5

HAVE I SEEN IT BEFORE?

Yes, just like the first movie, I saw it in the theatre and I haven't seen it again since

BEST SEQUENCE

When Pennywise meets Vicky under the bleachers at a baseball game. It's a very effective echo of his scene with Georgie in the previous movie, and it's one of the best scenes to rely primarily on Bill Skarsgård's performance. And again, I do like Bev's scene with Mrs. Kersh, even when the CGI makes it a little ridiculous

BEST LINE

"Let's kill this fucking clown"
- Richie Tozier

ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE

62%

ROTTEN TOMATOES CRITICS CONSENSUS

"IT: Chapter Two proves bigger doesn't always mean scarier for horror sequels, but a fine cast and faithful approach to the source material keep this follow-up afloat"

IMDB SYNOPSIS

"Twenty-seven years after their first encounter with the terrifying Pennywise, the Losers Club have grown up and moved away, until a devastating phone call brings them back"

DIRECTOR

Andy Muschietti

MAIN CAST

Bill SkarsgÃ¥rd, James McAvoy, Jessica Chastain, Bill Hader, Isaiah Mustafa, Jay Ryan, James Ransone, Andy Bean

THOUGHTS
  • It's actually kind of fascinating that the previous movie was so successful in ways that this one whiffs so completely. They both had the same director, the screenwriter (Gary Dauberman) also co-wrote the original, and the plot is a continuation of the same story with the same main antagonist; it would seem that all the pieces would fall into place to make an equally effective second chapter and it honestly makes you wonder why this failed to happen. Was this movie just hamstrung by the fact that these events happening to kids is more interesting and novel than with adults? Was it an issue with needing to depict the somewhat ineffective climax from the book? Did they purposefully try to approach the filmmaking differently to make the two movies distinct from one another, or did they make the wrong conclusions about what made the original so good? The world may never know
  • In my previous review I wondered what distinguishes good jump scares from bad ones, and conveniently enough I think this movie serves as a pretty good demonstration of when they're used poorly. Firstly, there are just too many - it's basically the only trick this movie has to play and we get numb to them pretty quickly. The rhythm and pacing are also off - jump scares are best used to punctuate tension, but they come so fast and furious in this movie that they don't have enough time to breathe and there's barely enough tension to even punctuate
  • And speaking of tension, while I liked the comedic moments in the previous movie, in this one they largely fall flat and, more importantly, they pop up at the weirdest times when they actually work against this movie's attempts to scare us. A real clash of tones. Although I did like the jokes about Bill's inability to write a good ending to any of his books
  • Which, of course, is a very thinly veiled jab at the climax of the book IT, which I've spoken about before, mostly about how underwhelming it was that the IT entity turned out to be just a big spider monster. So with this in mind, I was actually OK with the final monster keeping the appearance of Pennywise all the way up until its death, although this does kind of distract from the fact that Pennywise isn't actually IT, Pennywise is just an appearance that IT found effective in luring and killing kids. It was nice that we got some more of SkarsgÃ¥rd's performance, though, and I liked that the climactic battle had some more layers to it, including splitting the Losers up for their own individual scenes
  • Way too much CGI, and used badly in a way that distracts instead of thrills. There was CGI used in the first movie too, of course, but I feel like in the first movie it was used to enhance what we were seeing; in this one it was basically all that we were getting at times
  • If there's one thing this movie got right, though, it's the casting. The cast is almost all great and, very impressively, they pretty much nailed the important aspect of making it seem like these characters really are the grown-up versions of the kids from the previous movie, not just in looks but in behaviours too. Bill Hader as Richie and James Ransone as Eddie are standouts, and it's amazing how much Ransone looks like Jack Dylan Grazer, who played Eddie as a kid. The only dud is Jay Ryan as Ben - maybe he was underserved by the script, but he's a very forgettable part of the movie
  • And so, that will wrap up our time in Derry. While IT Chapter One was the most successful adaptation of its sections of the book, and while it's always fun to see these things depicted on screen, the movies definitely did not surpass my appreciation for the book, and really this whole experience made me want to read it again
Up next: But we're not done with Stephen King quite yet! It's Pet Sematary, and more specifically the original movie adaptation from 1989. And even more exciting, it will be our first guest review! So if you're getting sick of hearing me prattle on about Stephen King, you're in luck - my wife, Ashley, will prattle on in my place!

Sunday, December 3, 2023

READERS' CHOICE #34-B: IT CHAPTER ONE (2017)

THRILL SCALE 1-10

9

HAVE I SEEN IT BEFORE?

Yes, in the theatre when it came out, and I don't believe I've seen it again since

BEST SEQUENCE

It may have been surprising when I didn't even mention the scene where Georgie meets Pennywise in my previous review, and I probably should have - it's an iconic scene and it was totally fine when Tim Curry performed it. I'll give it the edge in this movie, though. Bill SkarsgÃ¥rd is terrifying and it's a perfect introduction to his take on the character - immediately more off-putting, and more animalistic with the way he's constantly drooling and hungrily eyeing Georgie. The kid who plays Georgie is also a pretty good actor. It's just a great introductory scene, an excellent first scare, and it gives us an idea of things to come 

BEST LINE

"I'll take him! I'll take all of you! I'll feast on your flesh as I feed on your fear"
- That's some nice alliteration, there, Pennywise!

ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE

86%

ROTTEN TOMATOES CRITICS CONSENSUS

"Well-acted and fiendishly frightening with an emotionally affecting story at its core, IT amplifies the horror in Stephen King's classic story without losing touch with its heart."

IMDB SYNOPSIS

"In the summer of 1989, a group of bullied kids band together to destroy a shape-shifting monster, which disguises itself as a clown and preys on the children of Derry, their small Maine town."

DIRECTOR

Andy Muschietti

MAIN CAST

Bill SkarsgÃ¥rd, Jaeden Lieberher, Jeremy Ray Taylor, Sophia Lillis, Finn Wolfhard, Wyatt Oleff, Chosen Jacobs, Jack Dylan Grazer

THOUGHTS
  • This is a great adaptation of IT in so many ways. The actors are great and the characters feel real, and some of the best scenes from the book are brought to life (scenes like Eddie meeting the leper or the blood geysering from Bev's sink). Beyond that, there are also some effective updates to old scenes and some cool additions whole cloth - for my favourite scene I almost picked the slideshow projector scene, which was a nifty update to the kids flipping through a photo album, and brand new sequences include most of what happens in the house on Neibolt Street, like Richie in the room full of clowns
  • And speaking of Richie, again he's my favourite character, this time played by Finn Wolfhard. All of the child actors are consistently great, though, believable and genuine. It's also always fun to hear the kids swear like sailors
  • And, as Pennywise, Bill SkarsgÃ¥rd is chilling. The voice is creepy as hell, as are the unnatural way he moves, and the ways he can contort his face (that bizarre smile is just a way SkarsgÃ¥rd can position his mouth, and he can naturally point his eyes in opposite directions). This Pennywise is way scarier than Tim Curry's, and yet, SkarsgÃ¥rd is also so immediately, unmistakably evil that we do lose some of the playfulness in Curry's performance, the joyfully malicious way that Pennywise likes to toy with his victims
  • Also terrifying, the way that this movie uses Henry Bowers, who I've always considered one of the scariest parts of the book. He's not supernatural, he's just a violent, sadistic kid - a real danger as opposed to an otherworldly one
  • I would never call this a horror comedy, it's way more focused on the horror side of the equation, but what jokes we get are pretty funny and character based so they don't distract from the scares
  • Quite a few jump scares, which I've discussed a few times now - I have no problem with jump scares as long as they're done well. Although, while thinking of this review it also occurred to me, what even is a bad jump scare? What factors are there between effective horror filmmaking and hacky, uncreative button pushing? If anyone has examples of movies that use jump scares poorly I'd love to hear them, and hey, at least according to a few reviews, this very movie might be thrown out as one example
Up next: Wrapping up our time with Pennywise and the Losers Club, IT Chapter Two

Thursday, November 16, 2023

READERS' CHOICE #34: STEPHEN KING'S IT (1990)

THRILL SCALE 1-10

6.5

HAVE I SEEN IT BEFORE?

Never

BEST SEQUENCE

Whenever Pennywise turns feral and shows his yellow eyes and sharp teeth it's pretty creepy, and I liked the Losers' first showdown with Pennywise when they were kids. The fortune cookie scene was also fun. But the actual scariest scene was probably Bev's cup of tea with Mrs. Kersh

BEST LINE

"I'll kill you all! Ha Ha! I'll drive you crazy and I'll kill you all! I'm every nightmare you've ever had! I am your worst dream come true! I'M EVERYTHING YOU EVER WERE AFRAID OF!"
- Pennywise, almost jumping out of a picture in a photo album to threaten the kids

ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE

68%

ROTTEN TOMATOES CRITICS CONSENSUS

"Though hampered by an uneven second half, IT supplies a wealth of funhouse thrills and an indelible turn from Tim Curry as Pennywise."

IMDB SYNOPSIS

"In 1960, seven pre-teen outcasts fight an evil demon who poses as a child-killing clown. Thirty years later, they reunite to stop the demon once and for all when it returns to their hometown."

DIRECTOR

Tommy Lee Wallace

MAIN CAST

Tim Curry, Richard Thomas and Jonathan Brandis, Annette O'Toole and Emily Perkins, John Ritter and Brandon Crane, Harry Anderson and Seth Green, Dennis Christopher and Adam Faraizl, Tim Reid and Marlon Taylor, Richard Masur and Ben Heller 

THOUGHTS
  • To avoid confusion, when I'm referring to the movie, the book or the character, I'll use capital letters for IT
  • Stephen King is my favourite author, and IT is my favourite book - not just by King, at this point I think it's safe to say it's my favourite book, period. I first read it in high school, and since then I've probably read it at least 6 or 7 more times, which is not nothing for a book that weighs in at over 1,100 pages. It's definitely one of his scariest books, but it's also so much more than that. I love it for the characters and the world, the little details and the broad strokes. Give or take a couple of multidimensional entities, IT has a relatively simple plot - seven kids get scared and hunted by a shapeshifting monster, they fight it, and then they do the same thing 27 years later as adults. However the book contains so many memorable tangents and vignettes that might not be essential to the plot but they all combine to equal one of the most fulfilling reading experiences I've ever had
  • Which is all to say that we're here to discuss the adaptations of the book, not the book itself. I don't think a movie needs to be 100% faithful to a great book in order to be a great work in its own right (and Kubrick's adaptation of The Shining is actually a pretty great example of this in how it deviates from its source material), but I do think anyone adapting IT has an uphill battle in deciding what to show and what to cut, and I think it's fair to remember that I know exactly how great this story can be and it's pretty impossible to force myself to ignore something like that
  • So yes, somehow this was my first time seeing the 1990 TV miniseries IT, and I'll be honest, I was prepared to be underwhelmed. I expected Tim Curry to be fun as Pennywise, but I didn't really expect much else to hold up very well. I'm happy to say, though, that I was quite entertained throughout the whole 3+ hours! 6.5/10 might seem like a pretty underwhelmed Thrill Score, but I liked a lot of the choices that were made and it's fun to see a new depiction of a work you're familiar with
  • But is it scary? There's the rub. They were definitely a little hamstrung by making this for network TV and needing to tone down the violence and the disturbing imagery (although it did still get darker at times than I expected). I'm positive that most people think of Tim Curry's Pennywise when they think of this movie, and I have no doubt that he caused a lot of nightmares for kids who saw this at an early age, but he just wasn't that scary. Fun to watch, and delightfully malevolent, but aside from a few intense scenes and some effective makeup work he was more comical than anything. It is a great performance, though, to the point where it might be very surprising to learn that Pennywise had less than 20 minutes of screentime for the whole movie
  • So outside of Pennywise we mostly have scares coming from IT terrorizing the Losers Club in other guises. Some are scarier than others, but when adult Bev goes back to her childhood home and meets the woman living there, Mrs. Kersh, it was the most chilling scene for me, especially when Mrs. Kersh morphs into a twisted version of Bev's father
  • As much as I've rhapsodized about the book IT, however, there is one aspect of the story that I've always found disappointing, even going back to my very first time reading it - the fact that the creature IT, this all-powerful shapeshifting being who can read minds and turn into its victim's darkest fear, eventually had one final physical form and it was essentially just a big spider. For a book that was bursting with limitless creativity this was just such a letdown for a big climactic battle, and this movie definitely did not change my mind on that front. The creature effect was kind of fun in a very cheesy way, but it deflated a lot of tension. And I laughed out loud when the main characters defeated IT once and for all by basically just beating the hell out of it
  • And speaking of the Losers Club (the self-appointed nickname for the seven main characters), I thought the actors were pretty good for the most part. Seth Green was my favourite kid as Richie (and he would go on to have the biggest career of all the child actors by far), but ironically Harry Anderson was my least favourite adult actor, also as Richie. I have a fondness for Harry Anderson, and I've liked him in other things, but as Richie he was just annoying and without any of the more endearing qualities found in Seth Green's performance or in the character from the book (probably my favourite book character, incidentally)
  • So, in conclusion, I'm glad I finally got to watch this movie/miniseries. I don't think there's anything that it did better than the book, but that's an extremely high bar to clear for me and it was great to see some of this story brought to life. Also, if they hadn't decided to make a few changes to the source material we never would have gotten to see Bill's sweet, sweet ponytail
Up next: We'll find out if the 2017 movie IT Chapter One is a more effective adaptation than this one (spoiler alert, it is). But it's been quite some time since the last time I saw it, so how much more effective honestly remains to be seen

Saturday, November 11, 2023

READERS' CHOICE #35: DONNIE DARKO (2001)

THRILL SCALE 1-10

7

HAVE I SEEN IT BEFORE?

Yes, but not for a very long time. Maybe not since university, but maybe not since high school (which would have been when it was released or shortly after)

BEST SEQUENCE

When Frank appears in the movie theatre

BEST LINE

"Why are you wearing that stupid bunny suit?" "Why are you wearing that stupid man suit?"

ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE

87%

ROTTEN TOMATOES CRITICS CONSENSUS

"Richard Kelly's debut feature Donnie Darko is a daring, original vision, packed with jarring ideas and intelligence and featuring a remarkable performance from Jake Gyllenhaal as the troubled title character."

IMDB SYNOPSIS

"After narrowly escaping a bizarre accident, a troubled teenager is plagued by visions of a man in a large rabbit suit who manipulates him to commit a series of crimes."

DIRECTOR

Richard Kelly

MAIN CAST

Jake Gyllenhaal, Jena Malone, James Duval, Maggie Gyllenhaal

THOUGHTS
  • Having not seen Donnie Darko for a long time, I remembered liking it but I didn't consider it a favourite of mine. Upon rewatch, that sentiment pretty much stands. It's worth watching but also kind of a mixed bag, and maybe not as effective as some people remember
  • Frank the Rabbit is genuinely creepy and anytime he shows up there's a shiver down the spine, including a couple of pretty good jump scares. His voice is also extremely unnerving. However, he's quite a bit less scary once we learn that he is, indeed, just a guy in a Halloween rabbit suit
  • Jake Gyllenhaal is really fantastic in this, one of his first starring roles (October Sky came out 2 years earlier, another movie that I quite like). As Donnie he's very likeable, while still legitimately off-putting at times. It's a tricky balance to pull off, and also somewhat similar to how I described his performance as Lou in Nightcrawler, a connection I didn't even remember until about halfway through Donnie Darko, as the two characters share some qualities but they're still very distinct performances. Unless some surprise movies get added to my list this is the last we'll see of Jake Gyllenhaal and he's had a pretty great showing in these reviews. Looking at his filmography, there are even a few other thrilling movies that may have been considered, including Zodiac, Prisoners and Source Code
  • A few times during this watch I thought, "wow, they're really trying to be edgy." And while I think there's some truth to that and while I think the movie is most effective when the effort to be edgy isn't quite so obvious, it may also be fair to acknowledge that it's easy to forget that the movie is set in 1988, a fact which is even easier to forget watching the movie 20+ years after its release date in 2001. So I'll give a little bit of a concession that perhaps what I perceived as forced edginess was also intended to show the general awfulness of people in the Reagan-era 1980s
  • The plot is convoluted, but in a good way, a way that intrigues instead of frustrates. When I sat down to watch it on my streaming service of choice the runtime said 2 hours and 13 minutes, and I thought there was no way that could be right. In fact, I had accidentally pulled up the Director's Cut, which is something I've had to consider a few times in this blog. I decided to forgo the Director's Cut in favour of the theatrical version, since the general consensus online is that the longer version mostly just over explains the plot and, therefore, removes some of the ambiguity and mystery. Any Director's Cut defenders out there?
  • Very strange to see Seth Rogen in a tiny role with very little to do, and as a really terrible person. It was his first movie but he was also in Freaks and Geeks on TV previously (which wasn't exactly a smash hit at the time, so maybe the small part in Donnie Darko shouldn't be surprising, but still strange to see)
  • Also someone who'd go on to bigger things, including the horror genre, Daveigh Chase plays Donnie's younger sister. A year later she'd play Samara in The Ring (not to mention the voice of Lilo in Lilo and Stitch, also released in 2002)
  • Great soundtrack, including several songs that I will forever associate with Donnie Darko - "The Killing Moon" by Echo and the Bunnymen, "Mad World" covered by Gary Jules (originally by Tears for Fears) and "Head Over Heels" also by Tears for Fears. Richard Kelly originally wanted to use "Never Tear Us Apart" by INXS for the opening scene, which is funny to think about considering how appropriate it was to start the movie with a song by a band called Echo and the Bunnymen. One might even call it a little on the nose with how much we'd be seeing of a sinister-looking bunnyman
  • Finally, a couple of references to other movies we'll be talking about: the movie that Donnie and Gretchen are watching in the theatre when Frank appears is The Evil Dead. Evil Dead II is #25 on the readers' list, and I might even review The Evil Dead as well when that comes along. As well, early in the movie there's a shot of Donnie's mother reading Stephen King's book IT, which I'll be reviewing...
Up next: Yep, that's right! Coincidentally, after a quick cameo in Donnie Darko, it's time to review IT (which I'll continue to spell with all capitals, since it gets incredibly confusing at times to talk about the book/movie and not just read it as a pronoun; hopefully information technology doesn't need to be discussed in the following reviews). And yes, reviews! Because that's not all, folks, we'll be looking at all the variations of IT, starting with the 1990 TV miniseries which, believe it or not, I have never seen. See you next time, when we'll all float down here!